Interleukin-12 plays a major role in immunity to intracellular pathogens by governing the development of IFNγ-dependent host resistance. Nevertheless, unregulated IL-12 synthesis can lead to immunopathology, an outcome prevented by the concurrent expression of interleukin-10. Dendritic cells (DC) are an important source of the initial IL-12 stimulated by microbial agents. Here, we show that, following systemic triggering, DC can no longer be restimulated to produce IL-12 in vivo while continuing to respond in vitro. When infected with Toxoplasma gondii during this refractory state, mice mount impaired acute IFNγ responses and, in the case of IL-10-deficient animals, are protected from cytokine-induced mortality. These findings demonstrate a previously unrecognized form of immunologic paralysis involving DC that can protect from infection-induced immunopathology.